Easy Chocolate Peanut Butter Candy Pie

Happy Tuesday everybody! I hope you had a very joyful and restful Easter. 


 It seems like I’m always late to the party (literally, sometimes!). For weeks I planned on sharing this pie recipe with you guys for Easter. I made it, (my brother) photographed it, and then… didn’t post it. Bummer. 

This past weekend was so crazy. Around Christmas I tried to get an in home baking business going but unfortunately, got sick which ended that. So this past weekend I had the brilliant (not) idea of setting up a booth with some baked goodies at an Easter egg hunt event. 

Well, what can I say? I love food. I mean, it really excites me. Give me a party involving meal/snack/dessert planning, and I’m going to go crazy – that is, before I resign and just ask to order pizza. But it really excites me that much. So I’m sure after that statement, it will be no surprise to learn that I made way too many desserts for this thing. 


When the idea was in the early planning stage, I just wanted to make a few desserts. You know, like cookies, brownies, and a quick bread. It seems like that idea took off and ran away without me because before I knew it, I had planned (just picture my cheeks turning pink, here) brownies, four different varieties of cookies, two cakes, popcorn balls, chocolate covered Easter eggs, and a (not so quick) bread. While my cheeks are now red from embarrassment, it seemed like a good idea at the time. I wanted to offer plenty to choose from. 

In the end, I spent a crazy amount of time, for something that wasn’t worth it. 

And while you are all saying “I could have told you that”, let me just say, I know, it was stupid ridiculous but I did learn a valuable lesson.

The end.

Oh wait, I think I forgot something – this pie!  


My consolation. 

The whole point of that story was to tell you why I am just now posting an Easter pie, sheesh. 

Let me just say that this pie doesn’t have to be specifically Easter. Just remove the eggs on top and there you have it – a regular Chocolate Peanut Butter Candy Pie. 

I love this recipe as it is not only easy peasy, but quite exquisite as well. Chocolate…peanut butter…kisses…peanut butter cups…need I go on…?  It’s also great for taking to parties. 

Please, for my sake make this pie. It is so good and a nice break from time consuming desserts. 

I think we can all use a break now and then, don’t you think? 

Cottura felice!

The lowdown: This Chocolate Peanut Butter Candy Pie will be sure to be a hit. Without a lot of time and labor involved, you can take it easy in the kitchen and plus, you won’t be groaning when it’s gone in 5 minutes. Flat.

I hope you enjoy this family favorite of ours – we anticipate it every year! 

Easy Easter Peanut Butter Candy Pie
  • 1 6 oz. prepared or homemade - see link below graham cracker crust
  • 16 miniature peanut butter cups chopped (or 1 C. Reese's Minis, whole)
  • 16 oz. frozen whipped topping like Cool Whip, divided
  • 2 tbsp. peanut butter
  • 30 milk chocolate kisses
Garnishcandy coated milk chocolate eggs
  • milk chocolate kisses
  • miniature peanut butter cups
  1. If making pie crust, make and let cool completely before continuing (for recipe, see link below).
  2. In a medium sized bowl, combine 2 C. whipped topping, peanut butter and chopped peanut butter cups (or 1 C. Reese's Minis).
  3. Spread evenly on bottom of crust.
  4. Place chocolate kisses in medium sized microwave safe bowl. Microwave at high for 30 second intervals, until melted and smooth, stirring between intervals.
  5. Add 2 C. whipped topping to melted chocolate and stir to combine.
  6. Spread on top of peanut butter filling.
  7. Cover and refrigerate until firm.
  8. Once firm, spread remaining whipped topping evenly on top of pie (you can also do this before serving).
  9. Before serving, garnish top of pie (or individual slices, if so desired) with chocolate eggs, additional kisses, and peanut butter cups.
Recipe Notes

See link below recipe card for crust recipe (also, might I suggest that the S'more Pie that goes with it looks (and tastes!) extremely decadent?). :)
Remember, to make this a non Easter pie just remove eggs from garnish and voila!

 Graham Cracker Crust Recipe



  1. Reply


    April 10, 2015
    I love this pie! So sweet and delicious!!!
    • Reply


      April 11, 2015
      There's nothing like peanut butter and chocolate, right? :)
  2. Reply


    April 14, 2015
    Pie especially chocolate and peanut butter is never too late. Love this very much!!
    • Reply


      April 15, 2015
      Thanks! :^)


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.